Laurel Anna Learn Article #6

Where the War Went Next

By March 1776, the Revolution was nearly a year old. Ever since the fighting at Lexington and Concord, the Americans had kept the British redcoats bottled up inside Boston โ€” until they hauled cannons up Dorchester Heights, high above the harbor. On March 17, the British boarded their ships and left Boston for good.

It should have felt like the finish line. It wasnโ€™t. Washington guessed that New York would be the enemyโ€™s next target, and one British general had already slipped out of Boston two months earlier with a plan of his own. That year, the war spread into new theaters โ€” areas where fighting takes place โ€” and two of them shape this story. One ran through the busy streets of New York, where a tavern on Pearl Street was about to witness more history than most buildings ever do. The other led south, to a half-finished fort made of palm trees off the coast of South Carolina.

Washington Rides Into Boston

There was little time to celebrate. With British ships still anchored in the outer harbor, Washington sent about 1,000 soldiers under General Israel Putnam to hold the hills above town on March 17. A second danger couldnโ€™t be seen at all: smallpox had been spreading through Boston for months, and most of the army had no protection against it. So every one of those first soldiers was a man who had already survived the disease.

A day later, on March 18, the general rode in to see the city for himself. Boston was battered but standing. Buildings had been torn apart for firewood, and homes and shops had been looted in the occupationโ€™s final days. Yet the British had left in such a hurry that they abandoned their barracks, their fortifications, and nearly thirty cannons. Many of those guns had been damaged on purpose, but Washington put workers to drilling them out and expected to save most of them. There was good news to send, too. John Hancock, president of the Continental Congress, had fled his Beacon Hill mansion, and Washington could report that the house, its furniture, and the family portraits had all survived.

Figure 1: Washington Before Boston Medal

George Washington Before Boston, 1790. Benjamin Duvivier, engraver; Paris Mint. Struck bronze, 68.6 mm. National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution (Record ID nmah_1121858).

Public domain (CC0, Smithsonian Open Access).

Source: https://www.si.edu/object/george-washington-boston-united-states-1790:nmah_1121858

Ten days after Washington rode in, on March 28, the town held a service of thanksgiving. Washington and his generals went in a procession to the old brick meeting-house to hear a sermon by the Reverend Andrew Eliot, then went on to a public dinner at the Bunch of Grapes tavern. One newspaper summed up the day: โ€œJoy and gratitude sat in every countenance, andsmiled in every eye.โ€ Eliotโ€™s sermon is lost, but one of his private letters captures what the occupation had felt like: โ€œWe have been afraid to speak, to write, almost to think.โ€

Honors soon followed. Congress had already voted Washington a gold medal on March 25 for freeing Boston, though the medal was made in Paris and didnโ€™t reach him until 1790, by which time he was president. Harvard added an honorary Doctor of Laws degree on April 3 โ€” a degree awarded for achievement rather than classes. Its students missed the occasion entirely; the army had taken over the college, and theyโ€™d been moved to Concord.

Winning back Boston proved something important: an army made up mostly of farmers and tradesmen could push the army of one of the worldโ€™s great powers out of a major city. Still, Washington didnโ€™t linger. He left for New York on April 4 and rode into the city on April 13 โ€” and that very day, the editors of his papers believe, he most likely ate dinner at Samuel Frauncesโ€™s tavern. First, though, we need to catch up with a British general who had a two-month head start.

General Clinton Heads South

Few British generals knew America as well as Henry Clinton. Born in 1730, he moved to New York as a boy when his father became the colonyโ€™s royal governor. He reached Boston in May 1775 and fought at Bunker Hill, a British win that cost so many men that Clinton called it โ€œa dear bought victoryโ€ โ€” one more like it, he said, would have ruined them.

Figure 2: Portrait of General Sir Henry Clinton

Sir Henry Clinton (1730โ€“1795), commander of the 1776 southern expedition and later British commander-in-chief in America.

Sir Henry Clinton, c. 1762โ€“1765. Attributed to Andrea Soldi. Oil on canvas. American Museum & Gardens, Bath, England.

Public domain.

Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Sirhenryclinton2.jpg

Meanwhile, the royal governors of the southern colonies had dangled a tempting promise: thousands of Loyalists โ€” colonists still faithful to the king โ€” would rise up the moment British soldiers arrived. So on January 20, 1776, Clinton slipped out of Boston with a small force. His orders were to meet a larger fleet from Ireland, under Commodore Sir Peter Parker and General Lord Cornwallis, at North Carolinaโ€™s Cape Fear River, and together win back the South.

The Plan Falls Apart

As it turned out, the Loyalists didnโ€™t wait for him. On February 27, 1776, a Loyalist force, many of them Scottish Highland settlers, charged across Moores Creek Bridge shouting โ€œKing George and Broadswords!โ€ Waiting on the far side were about 1,000 Patriot militiamen, who had pulled up the bridgeโ€™s planks and dug in. Somewhere between 50 and 70 Loyalists were killed or wounded; the Patriots had just two casualties, one killed and one wounded. Loyalist support in North Carolina collapsed.

Clinton reached Cape Fear on March 12 to find no Loyalist army โ€” and no fleet. Parkerโ€™s ships trickled in through April and May. With the original plan in ruins, the commanders settled on a new target: Charleston, South Carolina, one of the richest ports in America.

The Fort Made of Palm Trees

Standing guard over Charleston Harbor was an unfinished fort on Sullivanโ€™s Island, built by South Carolinians and enslaved Africans from palmetto logs with sand packed between them. Colonel William Moultrie was in command. Charles Lee, the American general sent to defend Charleston, took one look and called it a โ€œslaughter pen,โ€ warning that British warships would knock it down in half an hour.

 

Clinton intended to land his troops on the neighboring island and wade across a narrow inlet to strike the fort from behind. According to local guides, the water there was only eighteen inches deep at low tide. In reality, it was about seven feet. For weeks, his soldiers sat stranded, unable to reach the fight.

 

Parkerโ€™s warships attacked anyway on June 28, 1776. Hour after hour โ€” about ten in all โ€” they pounded the fort, and the soft, spongy palmetto logs simply swallowed the cannonballs instead of shattering. Moultrieโ€™s gunners answered hard. Three British frigates ran aground on a sandbar, and one, the Actaeon, had to be set ablaze and abandoned. Even the commodore had a rough day: Parkerโ€™s breeches were, as one account put it, โ€œliterally blown away.โ€

Figure 3: Sergeant Jasper Raising the Flag at Fort Sullivan

Sergeant Jasper at the Battle of Fort Moultrie, October 1883. Howard Pyle (1853โ€“1911), illustrator. Wood engraving. The Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Division of Art, Prints and Photographs: Picture Collection, The New York Public Library.

Public domain (published in 1883).

Source: https://digitalcollections.nypl.org/items/510d47e0-f563-a3d9-e040-e00a18064a99

Midway through the battle, a cannonball snapped the fortโ€™s flagpole, and the flag tumbled outside the walls. Sergeant William Jasper leaped down under fire, grabbed it, tied it to a spare pole, and planted it back where everyone could see it. His bravery later earned him a sword from South Carolinaโ€™s leader, John Rutledge.

By the end, the British had suffered more than 200 casualties, while the Americans lost about a dozen killed and two dozen wounded. The fort was renamed Fort Moultrie, and the palmetto became a symbol of South Carolina that still appears on its state flag. Less than a week after the battle, Congress declared independence, though the news took nearly a month to reach Charleston. Meanwhile, the battered British fleet sailed north to join the attack on New York.

Almost four years passed before the British came back for Charleston, though they captured Savannah, Georgia, in December 1778. When they did return, it was Clinton โ€” by then commander of all British forces in America โ€” who captured Charleston in May 1780, taking about 5,000 American prisoners. Sullivanโ€™s Island didnโ€™t end the war in the South, but it bought the Patriots precious time.

The Queenโ€™s Head Tavern

Long before Washington walked through its doors in April 1776, the building had a story of its own. Built in 1719 as a merchantโ€™s brick house near the waterfront in lower Manhattan, at what is now Pearl and Broad Streets, it was bought in 1762 by Samuel Fraunces, who opened a tavern named for Queen Charlotte, wife of King George III. People soon started calling it the Queenโ€™s Head. Today itโ€™s known as Fraunces Tavern.

Fraunces himself remains something of a mystery. He was probably born around 1722 in the West Indies, though no one has found proof. Some people in his day called him โ€œBlack Sam,โ€ and historians still debate what the nickname meant; the Fraunces Tavern Museum says his racial identity remains uncertain. What is clear is that he was a skilled cook and a supporter of the Patriot cause.

Figure 4: Fraunces Tavern, New York City

Fraunceโ€™s Tavern, Broad and Pearl Streets, New York, between 1900 and 1915. Detroit Publishing Company. Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division, Detroit Publishing Company Collection.

Public domain (published 1900โ€“1915).

Source: https://www.loc.gov/item/2016803173/

A colonial tavern was far more than a place to eat. Customers came to read the newspapers, strike business deals, and argue about politics. Among the regulars at this one were the Sons of Liberty, a group that organized protests against British taxes.

A Tea Party and a Cannonball

Boston wasnโ€™t the only city to dump tea in protest. In April 1774, New Yorkers refused to let a ship called the Nancy unload its tea โ€” then discovered that another ship, the London, had quietly brought in 18 chests. On the night of April 22, a crowd boarded the London and dumped the tea into the river, without bothering to wear disguises. By the next morning, a huge crowd had gathered in front of the Queenโ€™s Head to send the Nancyโ€™s captain back to London as the cityโ€™s bells rang.

The war itself reached the tavern the following summer. After volunteers began hauling cannons away from the fort at Manhattanโ€™s southern tip in August 1775, the British warship HMS Asiaopened fire on the city. One 18-pound cannonball crashed straight through the tavernโ€™s roof.

Plots and Occupation

By spring 1776, the tavern sat at the center of things. Washington dined there and attended a military trial there, and New Yorkโ€™s new revolutionary government met under its roof. Fraunces later claimed he had helped uncover a plot against Washington that summer. The danger was real enough: one of Washingtonโ€™s own guards, Thomas Hickey, was hanged on June 28, 1776, for mutiny, sedition, and treachery. (You may hear a story that Frauncesโ€™s daughter Phoebe saved Washington from poisoned peas; historians say thatโ€™s a legend from the 1800s. In fact, none of Frauncesโ€™s daughters was named Phoebe.)

That September, the British captured New York and held it for seven years. Fraunces was taken prisoner in 1778 and forced to cook for a British general โ€” a job he used, by his own account, to secretly slip food, clothing, and money to American prisoners. Near the warโ€™s end, the tavern hosted weekly hearings that helped decide which Black Loyalists โ€” many of them people who had escaped slavery and joined the British in exchange for a promise of freedom โ€” could leave New York as free people.

Figure 5: Washingtonโ€™s Farewell to His Officers

Washington Taking Leave of the Officers of His Army at Fraunces Tavern, Broad Street, New York, December 4th, 1783, 1848. Nathaniel Currier (American, 1813โ€“1888). Hand-colored lithograph. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Bequest of Adele S. Colgate, 1962 (63.550.436).

Public domain (Met Open Access).

Source: https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/661045

A Goodbye in the Long Room

November 25, 1783, carried the last British troops out of New York, and that night Washington and his officers celebrated at the tavern. Nine days later, on December 4, he gathered them in the upstairs Long Room to say goodbye before heading home to Virginia. โ€œWith a heart full of love and gratitude, I now take leave of you,โ€ he told them, and then he took each man by the hand. Colonel Benjamin Tallmadge, who was there, wrote that โ€œsuch a scene of sorrow and weeping I had never before witnessed.โ€

Peace brought new tenants: the building briefly housed offices of the new national government, while Fraunces went on to run President Washingtonโ€™s household kitchen. The Sons of the Revolution bought the old tavern in 1904 and restored it, and it has been a museum since 1907. Visitors can still stand in the Long Room today.

What It All Meant

Within just a few months of 1776, the war outgrew a single city. Washington won his first great victory in Boston and moved on almost at once. Clinton discovered that the Loyalist uprising Britain had counted on wasnโ€™t coming, and that a fort of soft palm logs could stop a fleet. Up in New York, a tavern that had seen tea protests and cannon fire became the place where Washington arrived as a general and, seven years later, said goodbye as a victor. And on a single day โ€” June 28, 1776 โ€” Parkerโ€™s ships fired on Fort Sullivan while Thomas Hickey went to the gallows in New York. Independence was just six days away.

Definitions and Phrases

Breeches: Close-fitting pants that ended just below the knee.

 

Commodore: A naval officer in command of a group of warships.

 

Countenance: A personโ€™s face or facial expression.

 

Frigate: A fast, medium-sized warship.

 

Militia: Ordinary citizens who trained to fight as part-time soldiers in an emergency.

 

Redcoats: Nickname for British soldiers. They were given this name because of the red uniforms they wore.

 

Sedition: Words or actions meant to stir up rebellion against those in charge.

Sources

Washington in Boston

George Washington to John Hancock, 19 March 1776 (Founders Online, National Archives)

George Washington to Jonathan Trumbull, Sr., 28 March 1776, with editorial notes on the Thanksgiving lecture (Founders Online, National Archives)

Honorary Degree from Harvard College, 3 April 1776 (Founders Online, National Archives)

Expenses of Journey to New York, 4โ€“13 April 1776 (Founders Online, National Archives)

Object of the Month, May 2025: Andrew Eliot (Massachusetts Historical Society)

Siege of Boston (George Washingtonโ€™s Mount Vernon)

Smallpox (George Washingtonโ€™s Mount Vernon)

One of the first to receive a University honorary degree: George Washington (Harvard Gazette)

George Washington Before Boston, United States, 1790 (National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution)

Congressional Gold Medals, 1776โ€“2016 (Congressional Research Service)

The Evacuation of Boston, 1776 (National Park Service)

Conditions Under the Siege of Boston (National Park Service)

Smallpox, Inoculation, and the Revolutionary War (National Park Service)

General Clinton and the Southern Expedition

George Washington to Major General Charles Lee, 23 January 1776, with editorial notes (Founders Online, National Archives)

John Adams to James Warren, 10 June 1775, with editorial note (Papers of John Adams, Massachusetts Historical Society)

The Battle of Sullivanโ€™s Island (National Park Service)

Moores Creek Bridge (American Battlefield Trust)

Moores Creek National Battlefield: Administrative History (National Park Service)

Henry Clinton (American Battlefield Trust)

The Southern Theater of the American Revolution (American Battlefield Trust)

Charleston Harbor (American Battlefield Trust)

10 Facts: Charleston in the Revolutionary War (American Battlefield Trust)

Declaring Independence in 1776 Charleston (Charleston Time Machine, Charleston County Public Library)

The Queenโ€™s Head Tavern

Samuel Fraunces: Revolutionary Tavernkeeper and Patriot (Fraunces Tavern Museum)

Fraunces Tavern History (Fraunces Tavern Museum)

The New York Tea Party (Fraunces Tavern Museum)

The Birch Trials at Fraunces Tavern (Fraunces Tavern Museum)

The Fraunces Women (Fraunces Tavern Museum)

Revolutionary Tavernkeeper and Patriot Samuel Fraunces (Fraunces Tavern Museum)

Pre-Visit Classroom Materials (Fraunces Tavern Museum)

Samuel Fraunces (George Washingtonโ€™s Mount Vernon)

General Orders, 27 and 28 June 1776 (Founders Online, National Archives)

explore our stories

Expertly crafted and written story experiences