lily clara letter 24 - buried treasure

Utahโ€™s Buried Treasure

Utah has more than its share of buried treasure stories, and a few of them are hard to dismiss entirely. The most well-known involves Butch Cassidy, the outlaw born Robert LeRoy Parker in Beaver, Utah, who led a gang called the Wild Bunch through a string of bank and train robberies across the American West. On April 21, 1897, Cassidy and a partner named Elza Lay robbed the Pleasant Valley Coal Company payroll in broad daylight at the mining town of Castle Gate, riding off with roughly $8,000 in gold. They cut telegraph lines as they went to slow any pursuit, and made for Robbers Roost, a remote stretch of canyon country about fifty miles east of Hanksville in southeastern Utah. The money was never recovered. Many believe it is still buried somewhere in those canyons, along with proceeds from other Wild Bunch robberies that may have been stashed in the same area.

 

A stranger story comes from 1846, when a wagon party headed west to California passed through the Great Salt Lake Desert. Among them was George Donner, who by the fifth day of crossing the salt flats had grown tired of hauling a heavy chest of gold coins. According to the legend, he buried it near a spot he called Floating Island, intending to come back for it later. He never did. Donner and 41 others in his party died the following winter, trapped in the Sierra Nevada mountains. Survivors of the group never returned to retrieve the chest, and the $15,000 in gold coins is believed to still be buried somewhere beneath the salt, possibly near a spring close to Pilot Peak in northwestern Utah.

Trees cut down by the Donner Party. Source: Wikimedia Commons

What makes Utah's treasure legends unusual is how many of them have at least a thread of documented history behind them. The robberies happened. The wagon trains passed through. The records are real. Whether anything is still buried out there is another question, and one that has kept treasure hunters combing the deserts and canyons of Utah for generations.

Nine Mile Canyon

Nine Mile Canyon, Utah 2015. Source: Wikimedia Commons

Despite its name, Nine Mile Canyon in eastern Utah runs for about 40 miles through Carbon and Duchesne counties, cutting a natural corridor through the Book Cliffs roughly 125 miles from Salt Lake City. Nobody is entirely sure where the name came from. One theory is that the explorer John Wesley Powell used a nine-mile measurement called a transect when he mapped the area in the 1870s, though even that is mostly speculation.

 

What is not in dispute is what covers the canyon walls. With over 1,000 rock art sites and more than 10,000 individual images, Nine Mile Canyon is often called the world's longest art gallery, and the title is well earned. Most of the petroglyphs and pictographs were made by the Fremont people, who lived in the canyon from roughly 950 to 1250 C.E. The Fremont were not purely nomadic. They built semi-permanent villages, farmed corn and squash along the canyon floor, and engineered small irrigation systems fed by Nine Mile Creek. Their rock art ranges from hunting scenes and animal figures to abstract designs that archaeologists are still working to understand. Later, the Ute people added their own images to the walls, many of them depicting hunters on horseback and dating to the 1800s.

 

The canyon's history did not stop with its ancient inhabitants. In 1886, the Buffalo Soldiers of the 9th Cavalry Regiment built a road through the canyon connecting Fort Duchesne to the railroad in Price, and Nine Mile became the main route for freight, mail, and stagecoach traffic into the Uinta Basin. A small town called Harper grew up around one of the stagecoach stops, with a hotel, store, and school. It is a ghost town now, its remains scattered along the canyon road.

 

Today, the canyon is a designated Scenic Back Country Byway, and the road through it was finally paved in 2014, a project that came partly out of concern that traffic-generated dust was settling on the petroglyphs and slowly wearing them away. More than 220 archaeological sites in the canyon are listed on the National Register of Historic Places, and the work of documenting and protecting them is ongoing.

explore our stories

Expertly crafted and written story experiences